Alamy; Everett Alyson Stoner joked that theirCheaper by the Dozen 2costar Taylor Lautner once made them question their sexuality "Almost convinced me I was straight. 🤭," Stoner said in an Instagram comment, reacting to a romance scene opposite the actor in the 2005 film Stoner identifies as pansexual and queer and uses they/them pronouns Alyson Stonerjoked that they had conflicting thoughts about theirsexualitywhile starring oppositeTaylor LautnerinCheaper by the Dozen 2. In a July 2Instagram post, Lautner, 33, shared a video of the 2005 film playing on an outdoor screen. The movie scene featured in the post saw the actor casually putting his arm around Stoner's character while they were on a movie theater date, as their film dads —Steve MartinandEugene Levy— watched on in horror. Turning the camera on himself, Lautner mimicked the scene that was shown, placing his arm around his wife,Tay Lautner, as she sat on a lawn chair beside him. Lautner referenced the scene in the caption of his social media post, writing, "The move still works 20 years later 😉," and Stoner, 31, popped in the comments herself and said, "😮💨 Got me good! Almost convinced me I was straight. 🤭." In response, Lautner wrote back to Stoner — who identifies as pansexual and queer and uses they/them pronouns — "OMFG YOU WIN," as his wife chimed in to add, "This is so good👏👏." Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE's free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. Michael Tullberg/Getty; Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Cheaper by the Dozen 2followed 2003'sCheaper by the Dozen.The first film, a remake of the 1950 movie of the same name, centered on a large family as they adjusted to their new lives in a new town. The sequel followed the family as they took a vacation and went head-to-head with a rival family. Martin, 79, starred as patriarch Tom Baker, whileBonnie Huntplayed his wife, Kate Baker. Alongside Stoner, the other twelve Baker children were played byPiper Perabo,Tom Welling,Hilary Duff, Kevin G. Schmidt, Jacob Smith, Forrest Landis, Liliana Mumy, Morgan York and Blake Woodruff, plus Brent and Shane Kinsman. The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now! Lautner starred inCheaper by the Dozen 2as Elliot Murtaugh, one of the members of the rival family the Bakers go up against in the film. Other members of the Murtaugh family included dad Jimmy Murtaugh, played by Levy, 78, plusCarmen Electra, Shawn Roberts,Jaime KingandRobbie Amell, among others Alamy Stoner opened up about their sexuality in a candid first-person essay published inTeen Voguein 2018. In it, they revealed that they'd fallen in love with a woman, before expanding on their overall sexuality. "I, Alyson,am attracted to men, women, and people who identify in other ways. I can love people of every gender identity and expression," they said. "It is the soul that captivates me. It is the love we can build and the goodness we can contribute to the world by supporting each other's best journeys." The PEOPLE Appis now available in the Apple App Store! Download it now for the most binge-worthy celeb content, exclusive video clips, astrology updates and more! Stoner revealed thatby coming out, they lost out on job opportunities. "I did end up getting fired from a children's show because they felt that I was unsafe, now that they knew I was queer, to be around kids," they said on an episode ofI'm Literally Screaming. "So there was definitely discrimination." Stoner is set to detail their life as a child actor in their soon-to-be-released memoir,Semi-Well-Adjusted Despite Literally Everything, out Aug. 12. Read the original article onPeople